top of page

SOCIAL CONNECTIVITY

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Youtube

From the Second Chair to the First: Learning to Lead Differently

Writer: Sean James
Sean James
17 hours ago
6 min read

There is a particular kind of leadership that happens from the second chair. In organizational leadership, the concept was notably explored by Mike Bonem and Roger Patterson in their 2005 book, Leading from the Second Chair. They describe leaders who may not hold the highest position in an organization but whose influence contributes significantly to its success.


I have spent a good portion of my professional life in that chair. As a Chief Operating Officer, Executive Minister, and Deputy Senior Advisor, I have had the opportunity to work alongside primary leaders in business, ministry, and government. Different organizations, different missions, different personalities. Yet, across those experiences, I discovered something about myself: I was really good at being the number two.


I could see things the primary leader could not always see. I could take someone's vision, understand what they were trying to accomplish, and figure out how to move it forward. I knew how to mobilize people and resources around a mission, identify weaknesses, strengthen operations, and bring some structure to what was often a very big idea. And I enjoyed that work. There was something deeply fulfilling about helping another leader succeed. I did not need to be the face of everything to know that I was making a meaningful contribution.


But something happens when you move from the second chair into the primary leadership role. I have experienced that transition as a CEO, and more recently, I am experiencing another dimension of it in pastoral leadership. And candidly, it has challenged me in ways I did not necessarily anticipate.


Being good at number two does not automatically prepare you for number one.


One of the more difficult things I have had to confront is that the skill set that made me effective in the second chair is not necessarily the same skill set required of me in the first. That does not mean those skills are no longer valuable. They absolutely are. But primary leadership pulls on a different version of you.


When you are the COO, you can spend a great deal of your energy thinking about how to execute the vision. You are asking questions about capacity, resources, systems, people, and performance. When you become the CEO, you still have to care about those things, but now there is another responsibility. People are looking to you to help determine where the organization is going in the first place. That has been an adjustment for me.


I was accustomed to receiving a vision and figuring out how to make it happen. Now, I have had to become more comfortable articulating the vision, making decisions about its direction, and helping other people understand what we are building and why it matters. It sounds like a simple transition when you put it on paper. It is not always simple when you are living it.


You have to change the way you relate to people.


I have also learned that relationships operate differently when you are the primary leader. As a second-chair leader, you often have the ability to move between the primary leader and the rest of the organization. You can interpret decisions, advocate for people, address concerns, and help navigate situations that might otherwise never reach the person in charge. You can be the person who understands both sides of the conversation.


But when you become the primary leader, people engage you differently. Your words carry a different weight. Your decisions are interpreted differently. Sometimes people are less candid with you, even when you genuinely want them to be honest. I am still learning how to navigate that.


I want to remain accessible. I want people to know they can be honest with me. But I am also recognizing that accessibility does not automatically eliminate the distance people may feel between themselves and the person ultimately responsible for leading. You have to be intentional about building trust, listening, and creating space for people to tell you what you may not want to hear. It also means recognizing that you now need the very kind of people you once were.


You cannot be the visionary and the entire execution team.


This might be one of my biggest ongoing challenges. When you have spent years being the person who knows how to get things done, it is incredibly easy to keep doing them. You know how to build the system. You know how to manage the project. You know how to organize the team, solve the problem, and make the thing work. And sometimes, doing it yourself feels easier than explaining it to someone else.


But I am learning that the more I remain buried in the execution of the vision, the less time I have to actually lead it. That is a difficult habit to break, especially when execution has been one of your greatest strengths. There is a difference between being capable of doing something and being responsible for personally doing everything. I am still working on that distinction.


Delegation, for me, is not simply about handing someone a task. It is learning how to trust other people with responsibility, give them room to develop their own approaches, and resist the temptation to step in every time something is not being done the way I would do it. That is easier to write than it is to practice.


The first chair can be a lonely place.


Another thing I am beginning to appreciate is how much the primary leader carries that other people may never see. When you are in the second chair, you are often close enough to see the pressure on the leader. You may even help carry some of it. But proximity to responsibility is not quite the same as ultimate responsibility.


There are decisions you have to make that will not please everybody. There are concerns you have to sit with before you have enough clarity to discuss them. There are moments when people need confidence from you while you are still working through your own questions. That can be uncomfortable. I think being a second-chair leader gave me a tremendous amount of empathy for primary leaders. But actually occupying that seat is teaching me things that observation alone never could.


I am learning to give myself permission to grow into the chair.


Perhaps the most important lesson for me has been accepting that I do not have to approach primary leadership as though I have already mastered it. I have years of experience. I have led teams, managed complex operations, advised executives, and helped organizations navigate significant challenges. All of that matters. But experience does not eliminate the need to learn.


I am having to develop some leadership muscles that were not exercised in quite the same way when my primary responsibility was supporting someone else's vision. And I think that is okay.


There is a temptation, particularly when you have been successful in leadership, to assume that every new role should come naturally. I am discovering that it does not work that way. Sometimes you are experienced and still learning. You are capable and still uncomfortable. You have a history of results and still find yourself questioning whether you are approaching something the right way. Those realities can exist together.


I do not share any of this as someone who has figured out the transition from the second chair to the first. I am very much still in it. I share it because I suspect there are other leaders navigating something similar.


Maybe you have been an exceptional executive director, chief of staff, associate pastor, vice president, or COO, and now you find yourself responsible for leading the entire organization. Maybe you are discovering that the position you spent years preparing for is requiring something different from what you expected. My encouragement, and frankly my reminder to myself, is to allow yourself to learn.


Do not abandon the strengths you developed in the second chair. They are part of what made you effective. But recognize that you may have to lead differently now. And perhaps one of the most important things we can do as primary leaders is remember what it felt like to sit in the second chair, because now we have the opportunity to develop, trust, and make room for those leaders ourselves.


I am learning that moving into the first chair is not simply about taking on more responsibility. It is about becoming a different kind of leader. And I am still becoming.

Comments


Graphic Spiral
SNJMS Logo (1)_edited.png

Sean James is a strategist, speaker, teacher, and podcast host who helps leaders build organizations where excellence is the standard.

CONNECT ON SOCIAL

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Instagram
  • Youtube

Legal disclaimer: The information contained on this site and our guides are for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, nor does it substitute for legal advice. Persons seeking legal advice should consult with legal counsel familiar with their particular situation as laws vary by state.

​

© 2026 Sean James and Associates, LLC. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy and Terms of Use

bottom of page